Monday, October 18, 2010

Digital Nation Response

In class we watched a video called Digital Nation. The two people that were in charge of the making of this video were Rachel Dretzin and Douglas Rushkoff. Dretzin and Rushkoff begin the video with traveling to the campus of MIT, which is home to the most Internet saavy students in the world. Many of these students, who have hardly known a world in which they weren't connected 24/7, admit confessingly to have increasing limited attention spans that make it difficult for them to read books or learn in ways not involving the Internet. One student from MIT says, "Honestly, I can't sit anywhere for 2 hours straight and focus on anything". "I teach the most brilliant students in the world", proclaims a MIT professor. She relates their habits of constantly using technology to "drinking the kool-aid" and "believing that a multitasking environment will serve their best purposes. But supporters of teaching with technology say its vital for educators to keep students engaged by using tools students use everyday. A co-principal of a New Jersey school says, "We have to capture the attention of students. We almost have to be entertainers." In this video they found that administrators at a local public middle school in New Jersey who credit increased use of technology with helping boost of both student attendance and standardized test scores. Some say they can multitask but a test done by a Stanford professor states other wise. He says, "Multitaskers are terrible at every aspect of multitasking. Beyond the schooling observations, Dretzin and Rushkoff observe the phenomenon of multiplayer games like World Of Warcraft and Second Life. The creator of Second Life thinks that technology is bringing us back together again. Besides the virtual world aspect they go on to observe aspects of warfare. They are people interested in joining the army by playing war videogames. They use these video games also for therapy for post traumatic war stress and trauma. This video went through all of the aspects of technology along with its uses and found there are many controversial benefits and negatives to technology. I agree that teachers need to compete with technology and change their teaching habits and update them with technology because my experience with teachers using laptops in a classroom environment then the opposing notebook and paper confirms it. When I use laptops and type up notes or do research I feel more productive because I can type and put down words faster than writing and I don't have to worry about legibility either. With a computer I can multitask easier than writing. I don't get as bored either with a computer. On the other hand with taking notes by hand, my handwriting is sloppier and my notes are more shorthand too as well. I feel if I use a computer I can make my notes more detailed because I can type quicker. A computer vs. a pencil is my way of choice 100 percent of the time no matter what the circumstance is. With my ongoing experience with technology, I think teachers should use the computers more often with students because I am sure many other students prefer using computers for an assignment than handwriting. With teachers switching to this method I think will increase class attendance and test scores, just like the school in New Jersey did in the Digital Nation video.

3 comments:

  1. In response to how teachers should involove people with computers more, I presonally disagree with this statement. I agrue that in the world we are having an ovedosage of computers. They have caused extreme addiction and even death in some cases. I think that for school, computer access should be limited more because as a nation we need to know when to say enough is enough. We need to learn better self-control when it comes to turning off the computer and engaging our minds into a activity that doesn't involve computers. Although it makes some people, like you, more comfortable, it can become a hazardous habit for others that can not fine the line of a resource and extra activity of there day.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree with how a computer can be more useful in situations such as typing notes faster and more detailed. Although Dretzin is right about computers and other technology being harmful to society, she sometimes fails to see how they are benefiting the world and how much more efficient things are. Although I agree that it is much easier to multitask with a computer, I also feel that I, personally, get very distracted and offtask when I'm trying to do reserch or type a paper for class. Stanford's theory that multitasking causes people to have short term memory and be more scattered is extreamly useful because it sheds light on the idea that doing things one at a time can be more efficient and that seperating tasks out gives them more quality rather than doing four or five things at once. I feel that computers give me this temptation to check my facebook, gmail, etc. while I'm tying to get something done. Although I disagree with Dretzin's theory that computers are all bad, I fully endorse her final conclusion that this need for techonology may be becomings an addiction for many people.

    ReplyDelete
  3. @TypicalJayne
    My feelings on the issue are mixed. I do support your position that the world is going through an overdosage of computer use, but I find that the arguement about how the world is becoming more modernized and we need to keep up with this ongoing change and the research done at the New Jersey school in Digital Nation of having more usage of computers in the schooling environment increased school attendance and test scores to be equally persuasive.

    @taylor.thetford
    Though I agree that when I use the computer I am exposed to the temptations of facebook and etc, I still insist that it is a matter of your own self control than the computers fault. Yes the computer is addicting but in comparison it means that you have low self control. When you have things to get done and you go on a computer, which has numerous tempations, and you first go on all of the things outside of your task, you have low self control, its not the computers fault. I personally the world's computer overdosage should be blamed as persuasion, not as an addiction.

    ReplyDelete